For centuries, artists have used oil as the primary medium for painting. It wasn't until the 1950s that acrylic paint entered the art world, gaining popularity in the 1960s. Nowadays, many artists choose acrylic over oil for various reasons. If you're new to the art world and unsure which medium to use, keep reading to explore the pros and cons of both:
Oil Paintings
Pros
- Drying Time: Oil paints dry slowly, making them great for wet-on-wet techniques and blending. This slow drying time is beneficial for beginners as it allows time to correct mistakes.
- Rich Texture: Oil paints offer a buttery texture that allows for smooth blending and intricate detail. Their thickness provides more control with the brush.
- Versatility in Techniques: Oil paints are suitable for a wide range of techniques, from glazing and impasto to wet-on-wet and dry brushing.
- Freeze Resistant: You can store your color palette in the freezer to keep the paint fresh without freezing it, saving time and money, especially for portrait work.
- Longevity: Oil paintings are known to last for centuries, though we haven't tested acrylics for that long.
- Finish: Oil paints often have a glossy, luminous finish.
Cons
- Drying Time: The long drying time can be frustrating, leading to waiting periods.
- Toxicity: The necessary use of solvents for cleaning and thinning can release toxic fumes and provoke allergic reactions.
- Cost: Oil paints and the additional materials like solvents are generally more expensive than acrylics.
- Complex Techniques: Oil painting requires a good understanding of layering, glazing, and mixing mediums, making it more complex for beginners.
- Staining: Oil paint stains can be difficult to remove from clothing and other fabrics, often requiring professional cleaning.
Acrylic Paintings
Pros
- Quick Drying Time: Acrylic paints dry quickly, allowing for faster layering and reducing waiting time.
- Low Toxicity: Acrylics are generally less toxic and have fewer fumes compared to oil paints, making them safer to use.
- Versatility: Acrylics can mimic the look of oil, watercolor, or gouache, offering a wide range of effects and finishes.
- Adhesion: Acrylics adhere well to various surfaces, including canvas, wood, paper, and glass.
- Cost-Effective: Acrylic paints are typically more affordable than oil paints, making them a great option for beginners.
Cons
- Quick Drying Time: While a pro for some, the fast drying time can make blending and wet-on-wet techniques challenging.
- Color Shift: Acrylics can darken slightly as they dry, making it difficult to predict the final color.
- Texture: Acrylics don't provide the same rich, buttery texture as oil paints.
- Brush Care: If acrylic paint dries on brushes, it can be hard to remove and may ruin the brushes.
Personal Thoughts
When I first started, I had no clue what I was doing. I wasn't sure if I should go for oil or acrylic. My advice is to buy small tube sets of both mediums and see how you feel using them for similar projects. There are many affordable brands on the market if you don't want to spend too much money.
It's funny how, when writing this article, I realized the important cons of oil compared to acrylic, and I can see why many artists prefer acrylic.
For me, however, it was oil paint love at first sight. I love the control it gives me, the vibrant colors, and the creamy texture. While I initially didn't like the slow drying process, I now appreciate it as it allows me time to think about my next move. Products like Liquin can help speed up the drying process.
To minimize the toxicity of oil products, keep the room well-ventilated and store solvents in tightly closed containers. You can also use protective gloves.
I believe oil is better for beginners because the slow drying time allows for play with blending and layering. I found acrylic to be harder in this aspect, as you need to work quickly.
Acrylic, however, is extremely versatile. I use it for rock painting and clay painting and find it less messy than oil. For certain projects, it's great, but for canvas painting, I prefer oil. This is my personal experience, and many artists prefer acrylic.
Overall, follow your intuition and choose the medium that works best for you. The love of art starts with the choice of medium.
I'd love to know your thoughts and which medium you prefer and why.
Add comment
Comments